Medievalists.net

Where the Middle Ages Begin

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Features
  • News
  • Online Courses
  • Podcast
  • Patreon Login
  • About Us & More
    • About Us
    • Books
    • Videos
    • Films & TV
    • Medieval Studies Programs
    • Places To See
    • Teaching Resources
    • Articles

Medievalists.net

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Features
  • News
  • Online Courses
  • Podcast
  • Patreon Login
  • About Us & More
    • About Us
    • Books
    • Videos
    • Films & TV
    • Medieval Studies Programs
    • Places To See
    • Teaching Resources
    • Articles
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Articles

Charisma, Medieval and Modern

by Sandra Alvarez
January 2, 2014

St Bernard in a medieval illuminated manuscriptCharisma, Medieval and Modern

Gary Dickson (School of History, Classics and Archaeology, University of Edinburgh)

Religions: 2012, 3(3), 763-789

Abstract

Popularized by the mass media, Max Weber’s sociological concept of charisma now has a demotic meaning far from what Weber had in mind. Weberian charismatic leaders have followers, not fans, although, exceptionally, fans mutate into followers. This essay aims to trace some of the dimensions of Weberian charismatic religious leadership in comparative perspective, medieval and modern. Examples include: preachers, “double charisma,” professors, “collective charisma,” religious radicals, the economy of charisma, transgressive sexuality, demagogues, living saints.

Introduction: The Heroic Individual and Max Weber’s Charisma

Heroic figures have peopled the western imagination from Homeric and Virgilian epics to the Chanson de Roland and beyond. Thomas Carlyle‘s celebrated lectures of 1840 were devoted to Heroes, Hero-Worship, and the Heroic in History, which surveyed religious, literary, and political heroes. Carlyle’s thesis that ―Universal History is at bottom the History of Great Men has long ceased to be persuasive, although variants of the idea have persisted ([1], pp. 1, 12). One example is Sidney Hook‘s protagonist in The Hero in History (1943)—the ―event-making individual‖ ([2], p. 229). But does historical significance determine heroic status?

Click here to read this article from Religions

Subscribe to Medievalverse




Related Posts

  • Charisma and Routine: Shaping the Memory of Brother Richard and Joan of Arc
  • Charismatic Performances in Medieval Literature
  • Columbanus, charisma and the revolt of the monks of Bobbio
  • Witnesses of God: Exhortatory Preachers in Medieval al-Andalus and the Magreb
  • Saint Anselm of Canterbury and Charismatic Authority
TagsBernard of Clairvaux • Cistercians • Crusades • Early Modern Period • Max Weber • Medieval Literature • Medieval Religious Life • Medieval Social History • Philosophy in the Middle Ages • Renaissance • Sermons and Preaching in the Middle Ages

Post navigation

Previous Post Previous Post
Next Post Next Post

Medievalists Membership

Become a member to get ad-free access to our website and our articles. Thank you for supporting our website!

Sign Up Member Login

More from Medievalists.net

Become a Patron

We've created a Patreon for Medievalists.net as we want to transition to a more community-funded model.

 

We aim to be the leading content provider about all things medieval. Our website, podcast and Youtube page offers news and resources about the Middle Ages. We hope that are our audience wants to support us so that we can further develop our podcast, hire more writers, build more content, and remove the advertising on our platforms. This will also allow our fans to get more involved in what content we do produce.

Become a Patron Member Login

Medievalists.net

Footer Menu

  • Privacy Policy
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
  • Copyright © 2025 Medievalists.net
  • Powered by WordPress
  • Theme: Uku by Elmastudio
Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter