Advertisement
Articles Videos

Magna Carta, the Rule of Law, and the Limits on Government

Magna Carta, the Rule of Law, and the Limits on Government

By Jesus Fernandez-Villaverde

University of Pennsylvania Working Paper, 2015

The opening lines of Lincoln Cathedral's copy of the 1215 Magna Carta
The opening lines of Lincoln Cathedral’s copy of the 1215 Magna Carta

Abstract: This paper surveys the legal tradition that links Magna Carta with the modern concepts of the rule of law and the limits on government. It documents that the original understanding of the rule of law included substantive commitments to individual freedom and limited government. Then, it attempts at explaining how and why such commitments were lost to a formalist interpretation of the rule of law from 1848 to 1939. The paper concludes by arguing how a revival of the substantive commitments of the rule of law is central in a project of reshaping modern states.

Take a look at our magazine
Take a look at our magazine

Introduction: Reading Magna Carta is a disconcerting experience. Instead of an eloquent expression of natural rights, such as the U.S. Declaration of Independence, or a well-organized template for institutional design, such as the U.S. Constitution, Magna Carta is an archetypical legal document from the Middle Ages. The language, even when translated from Latin into 21st century English, is unfamiliar. The chapters (the numbering of which was a later introduction to ease reading) cluster without a pattern, more the product of the haste with which this 3,550-word sheet of parchment was drafted than of serene reflection. Most of the chapters, in addition, deal with feudal matters of little relevance to anyone except antiquarians. Other chapters, such as those dealing with the Jews, are o ensive to contemporary sensibilities. After this reading, it is dicult not to agree with generations of historians who have conceptualized the Great Charter as a lieu de memoire, an ideological construction that sustains the collective beliefs of the English-speaking peoples in life, liberty, and property, instead of thinking about it as a relevant legal document.

Click here to read this article from the University of Pennsylvania

Jesus Fernandez-Villaverde also spoke about this topic at the New York University School of Law:

Sign up to get a Weekly Email from Medievalists.net

* indicates required

Sign up for our weekly email newsletter!