Posts Tagged ‘Maritime Studies’

By combining meteorology and archaeology, Norwegian scientists may discover old sea routes and mooring sites, and boost our knowledge of maritime culture dating from the ancient period to the end of the Middle Ages.

“Archaeology has a long-standing tradition in protecting areas on land. But unfortunately, there is little attention to cultural monuments at the sea-shore and under water,” says meteorologist Marianne Nitter at the University of Stavanger’s Museum of Archaeology.

“These may include mooring and landing sites, jetties, boat-houses, standing stones and house remains – objects which can inform us about prehistoric maritime culture and our ancestors’ mobility and travelling routes,” she adds.

Together with her colleague, geologist Lotte Selsing, and marine archaeologist Endre Elvestad at Stavanger Maritime Museum, Nitter has studied the protection of maritime cultural monuments.

These objects are very vulnerable, as they are exposed to rising sea levels, increasing maritime traffic and extreme weather, she explains. Tall waves and more frequent storm surges can obliterate them altogether.

“The process of recording underwater and near-shore cultural artefacts was initiated relatively late in Norway, so we simply don’t know how many of them there are. And we cannot protect monuments that are neither located nor registered,” Nitter says.

To help locating these artefacts, Nitter has introduced the concept of ‛climate-space’. Inspired by the term ‛landscape room’, this concept enables archaeologist to convey and incorporate abstract meteorological phenomena into the field of archaeology.

A climate-space is an area with homogenous temperature, precipitation, wind direction and wind force, Nitter explains. Valleys, groves, mountains, lakes, fiords and slopes are all examples of local climate-spaces.

The area is defined by topography and vegetation, which limits the occurrence of various weather phenomena. Furthermore, a climate-space is defined by calculating the weather phenomena’s time scale, the climate parameter to which you relate it to – such as temperature, rainfall or wind – and the topographic lines of the landscape. These three parameters are mutually dependent.

“The climate-space may change rapidly, and in step with changing parameters. Wind direction may change within minutes, and vegetation over a few seasons,” says Nitter.

Iron Age vessels could be landed in very shallow waters, which are now only accessible by dingy boats. As ships got bigger and deeper draught, a number of landing sites of the Viking and early Middle Ages were abandoned during the 14th and 15th centuries.

The climate-space concept is particularly helpful in finding the oldest seafaring routes and landing places. By using this method, scientists can estimate wind and wave conditions inside a fiord. They may also assess the fetch – the distance over which the wind of a certain speed blows – and thereby determine the height of the waves. By calculating wind and waves, scientists are able to chart landing sites which are no longer in use.

“By applying fetch and climate-space calculation to a particular landing site, you will see that the location of the harbour is adapted to the prevailing wind directions and most favourable wave conditions,” says Nitter.

After locating the best prehistoric landing places, we are likely to find cultural monuments, she asserts.

“Scientists have issued some alarming conservation forecast for 2050 and 2100. When sea levels rise because of global warming, the maritime environment is bound to change. How will we then be able to protect our cultural heritage?” Nitter asks.

Elvestad, Selsing and Nitter are concerned about Norway’s marine cultural heritage. They urge Norway’s Directorate for cultural heritage to consider the erosion of sediments, which – according to new analyses – happens faster than expected. Furthermore, it should take into account the rising sea levels, which will require protection plans to extend beyond the next century.

“The Directorate for cultural heritage should prepare vulnerability analyses of the most heavily exposed maritime cultural monuments,” geologist Lotte Selsing says.

There are two ways of protecting maritime heritage, she adds. One is to excavate the artefacts, the other is to leave them in situ – where they are. Some object will be preserved naturally, as they are sealed by younger sediments. Artificial sealing is less common, but should be considered as a protection strategy for maritime heritage. Yet another precautionary measure is to install a wave absorber, in places where rising sea levels are threatening the heritage.

Elvestad, Selsing and Nitter are continuing their work on protection plans and –strategies. They have now shifted their attention to the Bronze Age – a time when majestic burial mounds acted as navigation marks for seafarers.

Source: University of Stavanger

Ships and Fleets in Anglo-French warfare, 1337-1360

By Timothy J. Runyan

American Neptune, v.46 (1986)

Introduction: The most consuming military and naval conflict of later medieval Europe was the Hundred Years’ War. Beginning in 1337 and continuing until 1453 this struggle involved most of the states of western Europe although the principals were England and France. Edward III claimed the French throne by right of inheritance intending to remove the newly established Valois dynasty as usurpers. Dynastic claims or consequent ties of vassalage, however, were not the precipitating factors in the outbreak of war. Researchers over the past few decades have emphasized much more strongly the role of England’s possessions in France, especially Gascony, to explain the origins of the war. This approach recognizes the economic and strategic importance of English possessions and control in France as compelling factors in Edward III’s decision to initiate the conflict. French encroachments and claims on Gascony and other English possessions struck at the heart of Edward’s state – a kingdom which was transmarine.

Naval conflict in the English Channel and elsewhere between the French and their allies and the English was not a sudden result of the actions of 1337. Undeclared warfare at sea is the best description of the state of naval and mercantile relations between these parties extending back at least to the reign of Edward I at the turn of the century. Merchants frequently pirated or were pirated with the excuse that the other parties were the enemies of France or England. Truces seem to have been conveniently forgotten and suits to the crown were often the recourse.3 These appeals remain our record of these piratical raids. They were, in effect, crimes of convenience with convenient excuses generated to justify plundering.

The solution achieved at some point in the late thirteenth or fourteenth century to help abate this problem was the introduction of convoys. These were especially successful in the English wine trade routes to Gascony. Larger fleets of merchants often escorted by royal ships filled with men-at-arms could deter individual raiders or even small pirate fleets. But not all merchants could afford or were prepared to wait for the cumbersome process of gathering a fleet at a designated port, awaiting royal escorts to join them and then sailing a prescribed course to Bordeaux or elsewhere. Many ship-owners preferred to push on with their trade and risk encounters with French merchants cum pirates. The same held true for the French, although they were not as active in the trade of wine or wool which was so important to the English economy.

Click here to read/download this article (HTML)

Hanseatic Cogs and Baltic Trade: Interrelations between Trade Technology and Ecology

By Jillian R. Smith

PhD Dissertation, University of Nebraska, 2010

Abstract: The Hanseatic League was the major commercial power in northern Europe from the twelfth through the fifteenth centuries. During this time, it grew to encompass the coasts of the North and Baltic Seas and maintained economic influence over key areas on the European continent.

From the inception of the Hanseatic League until the midfifteenth century, one ship type dominated the inland and overseas trade: the Cog. Cog design remained fairly constant throughout the period in spite of the great geographical variation present within the Hanseatic League.

Cogs became increasingly larger throughout the period, requiring a greater amount of oak timber for their construction. The need for timber resources to supply the demand of the shipwrights was a driving force in the expansion of Hanseatic trade eastward into the Baltic States and Russia. Using the framework of Niche Construction Theory, the relationships and interactions between ship design, trade routes and environment will be investigated.

Click here to read/download this thesis (PDF file)

The Matthew of Bristol and the financiers of John Cabot’s 1497 voyage to North America

By Evan Jones

English Historical Review, Vol.121, No.492 (2006)

Abstract: The Matthew of Bristol is the vessel in which the Genoese explorer, John Cabot, sailed with his Bristol companions on their 1497 voyage of discovery to North America. Yet, despite the fame of the voyage and the ship, little has been known about the Matthew, or about Cabot’s relationship with his English backers. This has encouraged the proliferation of mythic representations of the voyage, in which the iconic Matthew is cast as a specially built discovery vessel and Cabot is portrayed as an intrepid and essentially independent explorer – a man worthy to stand alongside Columbus as a ‘proto-American’ pioneer.

This article challenges such representations of the voyage in two ways. First, it reconstructs the history of the ship to 1511 and sets her within the context of the Bristol marine. It is shown that the Matthew was a thoroughly unremarkable product of the Bristol shipping industry, which was simply chartered out of the town’s marine for the 1497 expedition. Following this, the Matthew returned to ordinary commercial duties, serving the port’s trade with Biscay and southeast Ireland. Second, the article explores Cabot’s probable relationship with his financiers. The aim is to demonstrate how far he was from being the independent pioneer of myth. It is suggested, instead, that his backers may have regarded him as little more than hired talent, a skilled navigator whom they employed to help them fulfil their own ambitions. It is also shown that Cabot’s relationship with his financiers and their port was such that, had his voyage been a commercial success, Bristol would have gained far more from such success than John Cabot or his heirs.

The article is accompanied by previously unpublished transcriptions from two documents, which throw valuable light on the history of the Matthew.

Click here to read/download this article (HTML file)

Taking the war to Scotland and France: The supply and transportation of English armies by sea, 1320-60

By Craig Lee Lambert

PhD Dissertation, University of Hull, 2009

Abstract: In the fourteenth century England’s kings embarked on a series of wars in Scotland and France. The ensuing campaigns ushered in a new era of warfare, both in its scale and scope. From a claim made by Edward I to be the rightful overlord of Scotland England’s kings gradually extended their ambitions until, in 1340, in a market place in Ghent, Edward III laid claim to the throne of France. Because the series of wars known to posterity as the Hundred Years War drew in most of the kingdoms of Europe as allies of Edward or the French it has been an area of fruitful and immense research. However, the majority of the studies completed thus far have tended to favour the grand personalities, such as the duke of Lancaster and the Black Prince. And to a certain extent the land-based operations that resulted from daring acts of chivalry have dominated the research.

Consequently, the naval element of the wars has received little attention over the last twenty years and has failed to capitalise on the new methodological approaches that have been adopted by some land-based historians. We are still uncertain, for example, how large the fleets were that operated in the Scottish and French wars, which ports contributed the ships, what was the service record of shipmasters that sailed on board these ships. Indeed, such a study should be seen as the first step towards a large comparative study between the army and navy payrolls and the particulars of the custom accounts.

This present thesis aims to provide this foundation. The study will analyse the involvement of the English merchant marine in the wars of Edward II and Edward III. The study will examine the fleet raising procedures adopted by the English government. It will also individually reconstruct each of the major fleets of the period, noting its size and structure. Finally it will examine some of the administrative and organisational changes that were developed by successive kings in order to exploit the kingdoms merchant marine.

Click here to read/download this thesis (PDF file)

The Development of the Rudder, 100-1600 A.D.: A Technological Tale

By Lawrence V. Mott

MA Thesis, Texas A&M University, 1991

Abstract: The one instrument which all ships have in common is a rudder. Until the 13th century A.D., the primary instrument used to control ships was the quarter-rudder system. Unlike the present-day rudder which is mounted on the stern, quarter-rudders were mounted on the sides of ships towards the stern.

The Mediterranean quarter-rudder was an inherently simple device and had only three basic requirements for mounting. This simplicity allowed shipwrights to adapt the quarter-rudder for use on a wide variety of vessels. Not only did the quarter-rudder concept permit the use of this type of rudder on different kinds of ships, but the basic system was also sufficiently flexible to evolve, thus insuring its continued use through the Middle Ages. As the methods for mounting the quarter-rudder changed, so did the design of the rudders themselves. The traditional Greco-Roman rudder gave way to the more efficient medieval rudder, which enhanced the overall performance of the quarter-rudder system.

A unique quarter-rudder system indigenous to northern Europe had also evolved, but unlike its southern counterpart, this system was rather inflexible. Northern shipwrights found that their system could not be adapted to the new ship designs which were continually increasing in size. This inability of northern shipwrights to adapt their system to larger ships created a technological crisis which forced them to look for a new device. The result was a rudder mounted on the stern by a hinge device called the pintle-and-gudgeon. Because this new device had several deficiencies, it did not immediately replace the Mediterranean quarter-rudder. Only after a significant change in hull design, and the appearance of the full-rigged ship, did the pintle-and-gudgeon rudder finally supplant the quarter-rudder.

The history of the quarter-rudder shows that technologies which are flexible are the ones which tend to survive the longest, while that of the pintle-and-gudgeon system is a classic example of a technology having to await the development of other before it can realize its full potential. The continued use of the quarter-rudder, despite some inherent drawbacks, demonstrates that there is a human tendency to try to modify existing technologies to their extremes, instead of immediately searching for more radical solutions to a given problem.

Click here to read/download this thesis (PDF file)

See also Professor Mott’s website on the War of the Sicilian Vespers

Seville : between the Atlantic and the Mediterranean, 1248-1492 : pre-Columbus commercial routes from and to Seville

Serradilla Avery, Dan Manuel

University of St Andrews, 21-Jun-2007

Abstract

The city of Seville and its port have had a prominent place in the history of early modern Europe and America. This city was not only the Gate of the Indies, but also the Gate of Europe for all the exotic goods and people that arrived in Europe via Sevilleâs port. How this city achieved such a prominent place has traditionally been overshadowed by its post-1492 fame. This thesis demonstrates how, during the two hundred or so years before Columbus, different groups were able to shape this city into a commercial port that had made it the axis between the Mediterraneanâs commercial routes and those of the Atlantic Ocean. Beginning in 1248, with the Christian re-conquest, the monarchs set out to create an independent and powerful municipality, as well as a merchant class with distinctive city quarters and privileges.

In turn, this merchant class affected the policies of both monarchy and city-council. Eventually, the policies of both merchants and the city-council led to the creation of an important exchange port that lay nearly between the two bodies of water. The Castilian monarchs, aware of this, also began the construction of the first Royal Ware houses and Dockyards, as well as determining the location of the Castilian Armada. It was those years between 1248 and 1492 that witnessed the birth of one of the most important naval ports of European history.

Click here to read/download this article (PDF file)

The Contribution of Venice’s Colonies to its Naval Warfare in the Eastern Mediterranean in the Fifteenth Century

By Ruth Gertwagen

Mediterraneo in armi (secc. XV-XVIII) – Tomo I, ed. Rossella Cancila (Palermo, 2007)

Introduction: Venice was a maritime economic power that was based on its maritime transportation, commercial routes and on its colonies. In the fifteenth century the Venetian Empire included Dalmatia and the Islands along its coast in the central Adriatic Sea and Albany further to the south, and consisted of Islands in the Ionian Sea at the entrance of the Adriatic, as well as of islands in the Aegean and territories in the Peloponnese. Notwithstanding the loss of Negroponte in 1470, the most important colony in the northern Aegean, the Venetian Empire extended to its maximum in this period.

Venice’s territorial expansion began, as we shall see below, in the late fourteenth century, not by conquests but as a consequence of the annexation with the local inhabitants’ consent, or by the request of the local rulers. Due to defensive motives Venice answered positively, preventing the fall of these territories to the hands of her rivals. The trigger to Venice’s territorial expansion came from the War of Tenedos/ Chioggia (1377-1381) that had a direct bearing on Venice’s geopolitical and commercial policy till the end of the first half of the fifteenth century on one hand, and on the other, the Venice’s naval power and warfare in this century.

Click here to read/download this article (PDF file)

Randall Sasaki – Ships of Korea – Koryo Dynasty – Nautical Archaeology Program Brown Bag Presentation 2010 from Ryan Lee on Vimeo.

Ships of Korea: from Koryo Kingdom (918-1392)

Lecture by Randall Sasaki
Given at Texas A&M University on January 21, 2010

Piri Reis’ Book on Navigation (Kitab-i Bahriyye) as a Geography Handbook

By Dimitris Loupis

Tetradia Ergasias Vol.25/26 (2004)

Abstract: The Ottoman Admiral Piri Reis (ca. 1470 – 1553/4) compiled in 1520/1 his Book on Navigation (Kitab-i Bahriyye), which was based partly on Bartolommeo [da li Sonetti]’s [Isolarlo] (Venice ca. 1485). His personal observations, though, are of great significance. For the first half of the 16th century this book of nautical instructions and charts (a sort of Isolano or Arte del Navigare) was the best hydrographical work on the Mediterranean Sea among other Italian and Spanish books of its kind. A larger second version appeared in 1525/6 and a third, not from Piri Reis’ own hand though, during the second half of 17th century. This work has a long manuscript tradition for a period of 250 years (till the end of 18th century). More than forty copies seem to have survived nowadays. Kitäb-i Bahriyye was the first cartographical work in Ottoman language and was used for a long time not as a book of nautical instructions solely, but as well as a Turkish handbook of geography and an atlas of the old world of the Mediterranean Sea in Turkish. Its latest copies pay more attention to the cartographical part of the work and less to the text. New maps of large scale are added in the luxurious manuscripts with the aim to produce modern atlases. This paper considers Kitäb-i Bahriyye as a geography handbook and atlas, actually the more original one in Ottoman-Turkish literature.

Introduction: The 16th century was for all peoples surrounding the Mediterranean basin an era marked by an intense activation in the sea and a constant and tireless effort to depict it accurately. Those states that could navigate that encircled sea were obsessed with the idea of perceiving and knowing the area. The Italian city-states, the Iberian kingdoms and the Ottoman Empire kept on being in trade and war among each other, registering their own dominion and that of their enemies and allies, and on making their presence felt all around the Mediterranean Sea.

On the part of the Ottomans, who are the latest settlers in the Mediterranean, a state establishment is consolidated at the end of the 14th and the early 15th century, anyhow, based on new, more stable grounds after the capture of Constantinople. The sultan, his court and the Ottoman scholars and scientists of this period are in close dependence on the learned tradition of the East and its achievements, even though they are a few centuries far from the classical Arabic production. Thus, the first works on geography, which are produced within the Ottoman dominion under the aegis of the sultan, are limited both to translations and adaptations of the classical Arabic or Persian geographies and to translations from Greek literature.

Click here to read/download this article (PDF file)